Or 18K or 24K : Which is the Best Choice for Your Jewelry?

In the glittering world of jewelry making, choosing the right precious metal is a crucial step. Gold, with its timeless luster and enduring value, comes in various purities, expressed in carats. But between 18-karat gold (sometimes called 750/1000 gold) and 24-karat gold (or 999/1000 gold), which is truly the best for your creations? This question, frequently asked by both professional jewelers and enthusiasts, deserves a clear and detailed answer. As your preferred partner in precious metal supplies, we guide you through this golden dilemma.

Understanding the Carat: A Question of Purity

Before diving into the heart of the matter, it is essential to understand what the term "carat" (abbreviated "K" or "ct") means when talking about gold. The carat is a unit of measurement for the purity of gold.

• Pure gold is defined as 24 carats. This means that out of 24 parts of alloy, 24 are pure gold.

• One carat therefore represents 1/24th of the total mass of an alloy.

24 Carat Gold: The Quintessence of Purity

24-carat gold (999/1000 gold) is gold in its purest form, containing 99.9% pure gold. It is often called "fine gold" or "pure gold".

• Advantages of 24-Carat Gold:

  • Maximum Purity of Gold: It is the purest gold you can find, giving it a high intrinsic value.

  • Rich and Intense Color: Its yellow color is deep, warm and brilliant, inimitable by less pure alloys.

  • Hypoallergenic: Being almost pure, it is very unlikely to cause allergic reactions, which is a plus for sensitive skin.

  • Prestige: Using 24K gold lends a certain prestige to a creation.

• Disadvantages of 24-Carat Gold:

  • Tenderness: Pure gold is a very soft and malleable metal. 24K gold jewelry therefore scratches, deforms, and wears out more easily.

  • High Price: Because of its high gold content, it is naturally more expensive.

  • Single Color: Its intense yellow color is magnificent, but it does not allow the variety of shades offered by alloys (rose gold, white gold).

  • Limited Use: Primarily used for investment ingots , coins, or for very special jewelry that will not be worn daily, or for techniques like Keum-boo.

18-Carat Gold: The Perfect Balance Between Luxury and Sustainability?

18-karat gold (750/1000 gold) is composed of 75% pure gold (18 parts gold out of 24) and 25% other metals, called alloys (such as copper, silver, palladium, etc.). It is the standard for fine jewelry in many countries, including France.

• Advantages of 18-Carat Gold:

  • Excellent Gold Durability: The addition of other metals makes it much more resistant to scratches, shocks and deformation than 24K gold. It is therefore ideal to choose 18 karat gold for jewelry worn daily (wedding bands, engagement rings, necklaces).

  • Variety of Colors: Alloy metals allow for the creation of different shades:

    • 18K yellow gold: Alloyed with silver and copper to maintain a beautiful yellow color.

    • 18K rose gold: Contains a higher proportion of copper.

    • 18K white gold: Alloyed with white metals like palladium, then often rhodium-plated for a bright white shine.

  • Good Price/Value Compromise: Although still valuable, the price of 18-carat gold is more affordable than 24-carat gold while still maintaining a high content of fine gold.

  • Quality Standard: Recognized worldwide as a mark of quality for jewelry.

• Disadvantages of 18-Carat Gold:

  • Less Pure: Contains 25% other metals, which may be a disadvantage for those seeking absolute purity.

  • Potential allergen (rare): Although modern alloys generally avoid nickel (a frequent source of allergies), sensitivity to other metals remains possible for some people, although rare with quality 18K.

Comparative Table: Difference Between 18K Gold and 24K Gold

So, Which Gold Should You Choose for Your Jewelry Creations?

The "best" gold does not exist in itself; it all depends on the intended use and your priorities as a creator:

• Choose 24-karat gold if:

  • You create investment pieces or works of art that will not be subject to wear and tear.

  • You wish to incorporate elements of pure gold for their intense color and prestige into protected designs (e.g., inlays).

  • Your clientele seeks maximum purity and is aware of the delicacy of the metal.

  • You use specific techniques such as Keum-boo (application of 24K gold leaf on silver).

• Choose 18-carat gold if:

  • You design jewelry intended to be worn regularly (rings, wedding bands, bracelets, necklaces, earrings).

  • Durability and resistance are essential criteria for you and your customers.

  • You want to offer a range of colours (yellow, pink, white).

  • You're looking for the perfect balance between the elegance of gold, durability, and an affordable price for high quality. This is the preferred choice for most jewelry designers.

Did You Know? Warranty Stamps

In France, gold items must bear a hallmark attesting to their purity. For 18-karat gold, this is often an eagle's head. 24-karat gold, less common in finished jewelry, bears a seahorse for new pieces. Knowing these hallmarks is a guarantee of trust for your customers.

Conclusion :

Ultimately, the choice between 18-karat and 24-karat gold will depend heavily on the nature of your jewelry project. 24-karat gold shines with its purity and unparalleled color, but its softness limits it to specific uses. 18-karat gold, on the other hand, offers an ideal compromise between the richness of gold, excellent durability, and a wide range of colors, making it a favorite among jewelers for the majority of their creations.

At the house of At La Fille Du Sud, we understand the importance of working with the highest quality materials. That's why we offer you a carefully curated selection of 18-karat gold supplies ( threads , plates , findings , etc.) to bring all your inspirations to life.

Ready to elevate your creations?

• Explore our catalogue of 18-karat gold supplies
• Consult our complete guide on choosing 18-karat gold wire for jewelry making.

• Need personalized advice?Contact our experts!

Don't forget to share this article with other jewelry-making enthusiasts!